The General Vs. The Plumber

Alan Stewart Carl responds to a Christian Science Monitor article that looks at the effect of Colin Powell’s endorsement versus Joe the Plumber’s symbolic resonance. The moderate blogger opines: "Do people care more about the decision of a statesman or about the concerns of an aspiring small businessman? The CSM article gives both sides of the story. But, as far as I’m concerned, Republicans’ fascination with Joe Wurzelbacher borders on the bizarre. I mean, it’s fine to give the guy credit for tripping up Barack Obama and prompting the Democratic candidate to admit that sharing the wealth is more important to him than rewarding success. But what’s with treating Joe the Plumber like he’s some Peter the Fisherman called up from his humble life to serve a higher power?"

He adds: "I guess it’s too late in the campaign to expect McCain to delve into the details of tax policy, or to expect the media to care. But this deification of Joe the Plumber by McCain and his conservative allies has left me wondering if they even take themselves seriously anymore. A political party really shouldn’t have to rely on a plumber from Ohio to make their case. I’m sorry if I sound elitist, but an endorsement from a general and former Secretary of State means more."